The Complete Fax Solutions Comparison Guide For Upgrading Or Migrating In 2025

Solution architecture is the single most important choice you'll make in your 2025 RightFax migration or upgrade. To help you prepare, we've put together a brief overview of the key decisions and trade-offs you'll need to make.

Generally, there are four ways to implement fax solutions at the enterprise scale:

  • With on-prem servers and telephony.
  • As a hybrid of on-prem servers and cloud telephony.
  • As a managed service (e.g., Private Fax Cloud®).
  • With only cloud services.

Basic comparison of fax architectures

Each RightFax solution architecture is best suited to certain fax volumes and usage patterns. For most enterprise clients, hybrid and managed models strike a good balance between control and data sovereignty on premises, versus quick implementation and ease of administration in the cloud.

wdt_ID wdt_created_by wdt_created_at wdt_last_edited_by wdt_last_edited_at Criterion On premises Hybrid Managed (Private Fax Cloud®) Cloud
1 IT support effort Reduced vs. paper faxes
and physical devices
On-prem benefits
plus reduced telephony management
Offloaded to vendor under
individualized terms of contract
Offloaded to vendor under
general terms of service
2 CapEx vs. OpEx CapEx Mixed (CapEx for server software; OpEx for telephony) OpEx OpEx
3 MFP integration Native (Ricoh, Xerox,
Konica Minolta)

Universal (SMTP,
XML)
Native (Ricoh, Xerox,
Konica Minolta)

Universal (SMTP,
XML)
Native (Ricoh, Xerox,
Konica Minolta, Canon,
Brother, Epson, etc.)

Universal SMTP
and XML
Generally SMTP
4 Software application integration Many native integrations Multiple APIs SMTP Many native integrations Multiple APIs SMTP Many native integrations (can be pre-configured) Multiple APIs SMTP Generally APIs and SMTP
5 System uptime service level agreement Managed by internal IT Server and software: managed by internal IT Telephony: offloaded to vendor under general terms of service Offloaded to vendor under
individualized terms of contract
Offloaded to vendor
under general terms of service
6 Data sovereignty/ownership Full control over server location Full control over server location Full control over data center location Generally limited control, if any

The implementation process

Private Fax Cloud implementations typically take just days to weeks, depending on integration complexity. Our highly specialized team handles all set-up and configuration.

Hybrid and on-prem implementations may take longer, and usually benefit from a hands-on RightFax consultant to reduce risk via project planning and implementation.

wdt_ID wdt_created_by wdt_created_at wdt_last_edited_by wdt_last_edited_at Factor On premises Hybrid Managed (Private Fax Cloud®) Cloud
1 Local server hardware/VM Yes Yes No No
2 Telephony equipment Yes No No No
4 Implementation timeline Weeks to months
(typical of enterprise software)

May require additional time
to connect telephony
Weeks to months
(typical of enterprise software)

No significant telephony deployment
Days to weeks Days
(if vendor provides new numbers)

Weeks
(if existing numbers transferred from provider)
6 Implementation complexity Highest Medium-high
(depends on existing telephony)
Low
(requires engagement with decisions and planning,
but not hands-on implementation)
Lowest
(minimal configuration decisions)
8 Customization flexibility High
(several APIs and complete control over servers)
High
(several APIs and complete control over servers)
High
(several APIs and complete control over servers,
via vendor)
Low
(limited to vendor's features and roadmap)

Pricing & CapEx/OpEx implications

All fax solutions involve some degree of operating expense. Server-based solutions may entail capital expenses, although it depends on the ownership and location of the server(s) and telephony.

Expense type wdt_ID wdt_created_by wdt_created_at wdt_last_edited_by wdt_last_edited_at Deployment location On premises Hybrid Managed Cloud
Capital 2 dev0paperless 08/07/2024 03:26 PM dev0paperless 08/07/2024 03:26 PM Fax server software Yes Yes No No
Capital 3 dev0paperless 08/07/2024 03:26 PM dev0paperless 08/07/2024 03:26 PM Fax boards or "soft" boards Yes Not necessary
(on-site telephony is optional)
No No
Operating 5 dev0paperless 08/07/2024 03:26 PM dev0paperless 08/07/2024 03:26 PM Monthly hosting fee No No No No
Operating 6 dev0paperless 08/07/2024 03:26 PM dev0paperless 08/07/2024 03:26 PM Charges per user No No No Yes
Operating 7 dev0paperless 08/07/2024 03:26 PM dev0paperless 08/07/2024 03:26 PM Charges per number No
(but telco may have separate charges)
Yes Yes N/A
(included with per-number charges)
Operating 8 dev0paperless 08/07/2024 03:26 PM dev0paperless 08/07/2024 03:26 PM Charges per fax page No Yes Yes Yes
Operating 9 License support and maintenance Yes Yes
(for server software only)
No
(factored into service cost)
No
(responsibility of application vendor)


The right architecture isn't always obvious. Unless you've already used and maintained a certain configuration for years, surprises are virtually guaranteed.

At Paperless Productivity®, our team brings decades of combined experience in enterprise-scale RightFax solution architecture and pricing. We offer best practices and illuminate risks and blind spots, so you can count on a resilient, scalable, and cost-effective fax solution.

To schedule a consultation, please reach out today.

Contact us

Request Consultation
Close